Content
Getting classified as a commodity would likely make cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin be more lightly regulated. While some regulators have said cryptocurrencies are not a security, initial coin offerings have been considered similar to other capital-raising practices in the securities markets, like IPOs. The cryptocurrency market’s identity crisis over whether it’s a commodity or security is important because it can determine how the space will grow and be regulated. But so far, the market has https://www.xcritical.com/ in a way challenged the traditional categories of financial assets. However, while being categorized as security could subject cryptocurrencies to greater oversight, it could also open the market to a bigger pool of investors after passing regulatory hurdles. That’s because individual or retail investors tend to have greater access to the publicly traded securities like stocks or ETFs.
Why Does the Classification of Crypto Matter?
I’m pulling Ethereum out of the platforms crypto asset class for now because it has special properties. Ultimately, investors need to convert their fiat currency into either bitcoin or ether to buy any other coin or token. While bitcoin and ether are different in many ways, they both have a market quality Prime Brokerage similar to one another and not shared by any other crypto assets.
Wellington Alternative Investments
Like commodities, they are interchangeable – each token or ‘coin’ is identical. Commodities are regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission securities vs commodities (CFTC). Presently the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) insists that the burden of categorisation falls on developers, who must demonstrate that their assets are not functioning as securities.
What is the Howey Test and why is it important in crypto regulation?
Defaults also freeze dividends and stock redemptions, safeguarding senior creditors’ claims.
Copyright © 2025, Capital Fund Law Group, LLP
In the U.S., the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) generally views cryptocurrencies as securities, while the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) treats them as commodities. These differing perspectives have set the stage for a fundamental disagreement in the approach to crypto regulation. Cryptocurrency classification significantly influences diverse aspects, ranging from issuer and exchange licenses to the legalities of selling and trading these assets. As the regulatory tapestry for digital assets becomes increasingly intricate, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) has stepped in, mandating the measurement of certain crypto assets at fair value. New accounting standards that will come into effect after December 15, 2024, aim to adjust entities’ retained earnings for a more accurate valuation of crypto assets. These regulatory advancements and reporting standards contribute significantly to the clarity and assessment of value and risk for investors, enhancing the rigor with which digital assets are scrutinized and understood.
I use these crypto asset classes because members of the set have similar properties. They have similar functional goals and react to the market in a similar fashion. They have similar valuation models, compete with one another in some form or operate similarly within their set, have similar regulatory risk and generally define the highest subset under the umbrella crypto asset superset. We believe bitcoin and other cryptoassets represent a new asset class that will increasingly gain the acceptance and participation of institutional investors. In addition, we think there will likely be progressively more specialization, sophistication, and use cases (such as DeFi and NFTs). While many participants are just seeking to get bitcoin exposure today, we believe they may be looking to build a broader portfolio of digital assets in the future.
There are the crypto indices such as Tom Lee’s 5 crypto indices tracking commodities, platforms, privacy tokens, exchange tokens, and stable coins. Bitmain Recently procuded its own crypto index tracking Currency, Platform and Privacy coins. Misclassification of crypto-assets can result in non-compliance with European and Spanish regulations, potentially leading to severe sanctions for companies operating with crypto-assets. It is critical for companies to allocate resources and conduct thorough analyses to ensure the proper classification of the crypto-assets they involve in their operations.
- To this end, ESMA has issued a consultation paper seeking input from stakeholders on the conditions and criteria for the qualification of crypto-assets as financial instruments.
- It might force some exchanges to delist it and halt staking operations, unless they possess securities licenses.
- The classification of crypto as a security involves a mix of risks and rewards.
- For instance, utility tokens allow the use of a product or service within a certain ecosystem.
- This could change as we’re in the very early stages of this new asset class.
- Getting classified as a commodity would likely make cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin be more lightly regulated.
While it can provide vital investor protections, it also subjects the asset to stricter regulations. Investments in crypto asset securities can be volatile and speculative, with potential risk for significant loss if not protected by the regulations applicable to securities. In our view, not only is bitcoin a store of value akin to digital gold, but it is also a call option on the future of finance.
When crypto assets are classified as securities, they fall under the umbrella of regulatory frameworks designed to shield investors from the dark arts of fraud and deception. This not only necessitates full disclosure of material information by issuers but also ensures compliance with anti-fraud provisions of federal securities laws, maintaining the integrity of the markets. The ability to sue for damages in the event of being misled affords investors a sword of justice against the potential malpractices of crypto asset issuers. The reserve crypto asset class contains just two coins — bitcoin and ether.
These complimentary downloads are dedicated to helping fund managers understand the legal fundamentals of launching and operating an investment fund. As a preliminary matter, US regulators have adopted no official designations for classifying token types, but certain terminology has been applied to various tokens based on function and property right. With the SEC’s gaze fixed firmly on the crypto industry, firms must tread carefully. The concept of a meme coin is still somewhat new, with popular examples like Dogecoin and Pepe building quite the calling. Some celebrities and well-known influencers have caught wind of these coins, helping grow value.
Commodities, platforms and stablecoins are of a different classification type than privacy coins and exchanges, and I would separate them as such. That way, we’ll have both asset classes and sectors like we do with traditional financial markets. In conclusion, the ongoing debate around classifying crypto tokens as securities or commodities is far from settled.
These evolving regulatory proposals aim to strike a balance between fostering innovation in the digital asset space and ensuring consumer protection. They also address illicit finance risks that could potentially arise from the misuse of cryptocurrencies. Amidst these debates, legislative efforts continue to fine-tune regulatory frameworks for digital assets.
I mention these disparate systems to keep in mind the reasons for classification as well as the difficulty in creating an exhaustive system to stand the test of time. Indexes and Indices are made to track market activity, not classify the world of crypto. However, it’s still useful to remain aware of how prominent investors view the market. Early this year, prominent industry participants, including Coinbase, ConsenSys, R3, and Circle formed an industry body called GDF. Global Digital Finance was founded to collaborate on industry standards and regulation.